Buster Bash is a retired wrestler who desires a quiet life after his career. Living in his small hometown of Currie Valley, Illinois, Buster is seen as a local celebrity and hero. One day, he is called to take care of a stray alligator that has been spotted in town. Despite feeling overwhelmed, Buster takes on the challenge, but soon realizes that he may have bitten off more than he can chew. Alligator Autopsy explores themes of small-town life, heroism, and unexpected challenges.