High school senior Jay Cooper finds himself amidst Julie Andrews's brutal homicide, after waking up from the previous night's prom with her. When the town's sheriff couldn't get any lead on cracking the case, Jay sets out to solve the mystery behind his girlfriend's murder, all by himself. But soon he learns a bitter truth when he starts receiving letters from the killer as the bodies start piling up around the town, juxtaposing with the murders that transpired nearly twenty five years ago. The utter town of Greenwood is immersed in trepidation and it's up to Jay and his friends to figure out the identity of the killer and cease him before he kills another teen from Greenwood High.