When Sarah's attempt at matchmaking ends in disaster, it begins a series of bizarre events that include at least one dead body, a mysterious stranger, an unwanted resident in a rancher's pond, a kidnapping, and Remy in charge of a growing menagerie. A chance meeting at Fee Reservoir has Sarah experiencing quite an attraction to Pete Yarbrough, the owner of the Silver Spur Saloon. After accepting his invitation to open mic night, she finds herself offering to haul his motocross trailer to a hare and hound race in the Nevada desert when his usual driver, and only pit crew member, is unable to go. While there, a collision and nearly fatal accident brings them even closer. A break in one of her investigations has Sarah relying on Pete's expertise of reptiles, and together they make a startling discovery. Of most concern to Sarah is the man who has interjected himself into Cindy's life. Dispatcher for the Sheriff's Office as well as a friend, she is unwilling to listen to Sarah's warnings until it's too late.