As the atypical small southern town, Baymont, Alabama holds but one unique, albeit tragic distinction, that being the mysterious, grisly murders of two former high school standouts the night of the Class of '81's twenty-fifth reunion. Hoping to shed new light on the bizarre, quasi-supernatural circumstances surrounding the twin slayings, a documentary filmmaker and his crew descend upon the town amid a general indifference from the locals, the majority of which regard all media-related types as little more than predatory blood-mongers and publicity seekers. However, as filming progresses and interviews with former classmates of the victims reveal a dark, sinister flipside to Baymont's tranquil surroundings, the identity of a possible killer begins to take shape, unlocking not only the shocking secret to the reunion night murders, but also the horrid truth behind a similarly gruesome cold-case from twenty-five years earlier.