An Amish man who has had to serve time for vehicular manslaughter returns to the town after years in jail. He insists it was an accident but feels the need to make amends to the family of the man he killed. The man owned a furniture shop which now isn't doing well financially. Using the skills he learned in prison, he helps them out. Their younger daughter resents his presence at first but the two soon develop an attraction that is undeniable. Will she forgive him and let an unexpected romance blossom?