Lenore is deathly afraid of her new father-in-law. Not knowing what else to do, she tries to convince her husband Abraham to leave the Amish town once and for all. But Abraham cannot see the wrong in his father and he refuses, believing that he poses no threat to his family.

But when Lenore disappears without a trace, both he and law enforcement are at a loss. Abraham struggles to find his missing wife while trying to provide some sense of normalcy to their son, Jacob.

Where did Lenore disappear to? And what happened to make her leave her husband and son?