Janice Butler is torn between being in relationship with a dangerous man and following the quiet voice of faith inside her heart that warns her of the tragedy ahead. The gripping story of her domestic violence experience is presented decision by decision as she follows the path leading to her frightful abduction by her husband, being a hostage victim, and his subsequent death. Torn Between Religion and Relationship takes the story to the hopeful end, however, as Butler discusses how she survived and provides hope to others that may find themselves on a similar path.